Michael Haneke’s latest, that won the Palme d’Or at Cannes this past May. It’s a powerful film about ageing, dying, and death—the most so one is likely to see on the subject—, and the love and commitment in a couple that accompanies this. And memories of a life lived. The film provokes discussion on a range of issues, notably on the question of euthanasia. With the exception of the opening scene it takes place entirely in a bourgeois Parisian apartment, with the lead characters played by Jean-Louis Trintignant and Emmanuelle Riva—age 81 and 85, respectively, in real life—, their daughter, played by Isabelle Huppert—who’s pushing 60 but looks several years younger—, and three or four passing characters. It’s an absorbing film, sad, and all too real for so many couples and families. Reviews in France have been dithyrambic, as could be expected. For US reviews, see here, here, and here. It opens in the UK in a couple of weeks, in the US next month.
Argo »
Amour
November 4, 2012 by Arun
Posted in Cinema | 7 Comments
7 Responses
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Categories
- Africa (26)
- Americas (25)
- Asia (22)
- Books (70)
- Cinema (257)
- en français (150)
- Europe (104)
- France (192)
- France: 2012 elections (83)
- France: Charlie Hebdo (18)
- France: DSK affair (44)
- France: politics 2012-16 (66)
- France: politics 2016-19 (35)
- Greece (24)
- Immigration (68)
- Iran-AfPak (34)
- Israel-Palestine (156)
- Maghreb (91)
- Middle East (160)
- miscellaneous (36)
- Music (25)
- Russia / ex-USSR (42)
- Sports (41)
- Turkey (68)
- USA (121)
- USA: foreign affairs (75)
- USA: guns (32)
- USA: politics (210)
Archives
- December 2019 (1)
- November 2019 (3)
- October 2019 (3)
- September 2019 (1)
- August 2019 (3)
- July 2019 (5)
- June 2019 (1)
- May 2019 (7)
- April 2019 (2)
- March 2019 (3)
- February 2019 (6)
- January 2019 (1)
- December 2018 (6)
- November 2018 (5)
- October 2018 (5)
- September 2018 (2)
- August 2018 (4)
- July 2018 (5)
- June 2018 (5)
- May 2018 (3)
- April 2018 (3)
- March 2018 (5)
- February 2018 (6)
- January 2018 (1)
- December 2017 (5)
- November 2017 (7)
- October 2017 (4)
- September 2017 (3)
- August 2017 (5)
- July 2017 (4)
- June 2017 (4)
- May 2017 (9)
- April 2017 (8)
- March 2017 (7)
- February 2017 (5)
- January 2017 (4)
- December 2016 (6)
- November 2016 (10)
- October 2016 (7)
- September 2016 (3)
- August 2016 (5)
- July 2016 (8)
- June 2016 (5)
- May 2016 (9)
- April 2016 (5)
- March 2016 (7)
- February 2016 (15)
- January 2016 (7)
- December 2015 (7)
- November 2015 (10)
- October 2015 (12)
- September 2015 (5)
- August 2015 (11)
- July 2015 (9)
- June 2015 (9)
- May 2015 (14)
- April 2015 (7)
- March 2015 (11)
- February 2015 (10)
- January 2015 (8)
- December 2014 (11)
- November 2014 (10)
- October 2014 (11)
- September 2014 (10)
- August 2014 (17)
- July 2014 (11)
- June 2014 (10)
- May 2014 (18)
- April 2014 (16)
- March 2014 (18)
- February 2014 (17)
- January 2014 (11)
- December 2013 (12)
- November 2013 (11)
- October 2013 (15)
- September 2013 (22)
- August 2013 (12)
- July 2013 (13)
- June 2013 (30)
- May 2013 (25)
- April 2013 (21)
- March 2013 (23)
- February 2013 (17)
- January 2013 (12)
- December 2012 (26)
- November 2012 (40)
- October 2012 (29)
- September 2012 (25)
- August 2012 (22)
- July 2012 (36)
- June 2012 (45)
- May 2012 (47)
- April 2012 (33)
- March 2012 (37)
- February 2012 (17)
- January 2012 (28)
- December 2011 (20)
- November 2011 (14)
- October 2011 (24)
- September 2011 (35)
- August 2011 (10)
- July 2011 (40)
- June 2011 (49)
- May 2011 (55)
- April 2011 (65)
Follow me on Twitter
My TweetsSuivez-moi sur Twitter
My TweetsBLOGROLL – FRANCE
- 28 Minutes
- 500 Signatures: French Politics & Elections Blog
- Acrimed
- Agnès Poirier: The Guardian
- AgoraVox
- Al-Kanz
- Alain Duhamel: RTL
- Alain Juppé: le blog-notes
- Atlantico
- Au centre, la banlieue
- Actualités du droit
- Blog de Mohamed Sifaoui
- Bondy Blog
- Brice Couturier: France Culture
- Bruno Roger-Petit: Challenges
- C dans l’air
- Causeur
- Chambres à part
- Charles: La revue politique
- Claude Askolovitch: iTélé
- Confusionnisme.info
- Conspiracy Watch
- Droite(s) extrême(s)
- Eric Dupin
- Extimités
- Figaro Vox
- French News Online
- French Politics
- Guy Birenbaum
- Halalbook
- Jean Baubérot
- Journal d’un avocat
- Justice au singulier
- La Page de Bernard G
- La Reprise
- LCP
- Le 19 heures de Françoise Fressoz
- Le Cinéma: France Inter
- Le Lab: Europe 1
- Le Huffington Post
- Le Scan Politique: Le Figaro
- Léa Salamé: France Inter
- Les Coulisses de Juan
- Les Cuisines de l’Assemblée
- L’Opinion
- L’UMP d’après
- Mediapart
- Memorial 98
- Nicolas Beytout
- Oumma.com
- Politeeks
- Public Sénat
- Rebecca Manzoni: France Inter
- Rouges & Verts
- Rue89
- Secret police: Marianne
- Sister Republic
- Slate.fr
- SlowPolitix
- Society: quinzomadaire en liberté
- Sondages Politique BFMTV
- Thomas Legrand: France Inter
- Titiou Lecoq
- Tocqueville 21
- Une année en France
BLOGROLL – EUROPE
- A Fistful of Euros
- Ambrose Evans-Pritchard
- Analyze Greece!
- Bridging Europe
- Bruegel: Improving Economic Policy
- Brussels Blog
- Bruxelles2
- Centre for European Politics
- Centre for European Reform
- Centre Maurits Coppieters
- Corporate Europe Observatory
- Coulisses de Bruxelles
- Council for European Studies
- Daniel Cohn-Bendit
- EU Democracy Observatory on Citizenship
- EurActiv
- Euro Intelligence
- European Council on Foreign Relations
- European Foundation for Democracy
- European Foundation for Freedom
- European Liberal Forum
- European Policy Centre
- European Union Law
- Europolitics
- Euros du village
- Foundation for European Progessive Studies
- Francesco Saraceno’s Blog
- Green European Foundation
- Institute of European Democrats
- Jack of Kent blog
- La Bataille de Bruxelles
- New Direction: The Foundation for European Reform
- Notre Europe: Jacques Delors Institute
- Organization for European Interstate Cooperation
- Politico.eu
- Sauvons l’Europe
- Social Europe Journal
- The Greek Crisis
- The Progressive Post
- The UK in a Changing Europe
- Toute l’Europe
- Transform! European Network for Alternative Thinking
- Wilfried Martens Centre for European Studies
- Yanis Varoufakis
BLOGROLL – MENA
- 2TS: Thoughts from Turkey
- +972
- A Separate State of Mind
- A Tunisian Girl
- Aaron David Miller
- Abed Charef
- Abu Aardvark
- Abu Jamajem
- Abu Muqawama
- Adam Garfinkle’s Blog
- Akram Belkaïd
- Al-Bab
- Al-Haq
- Alain Gresh
- Alan M. Dershowitz
- Algeria-Watch
- Algérie-Focus
- Atatürk’s Republic
- Au fil du Bosphore
- Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi
- Badil Resource Center
- Beirut Spring
- Bernard Avishai Dot Com
- Blue White Future
- Breaking the Silence
- Brown Moses Blog
- B’Tselem
- Bülent
- Burak Bekdil
- Carnegie Middle East Center
- Changing Turkey in a Changing World
- ChoufChouf (Algérie)
- Culture et politique arabes
- Elder of Ziyon
- Engage
- Erik Meyersson
- EurasiaNet
- Exit Left
- Fathom
- Fikra Forum
- Foundation for Middle East Peace
- Free Turkey Now
- Gaza Gateway
- Graham E. Fuller
- Guerre ou paix
- Gush Shalom
- Haaretz
- Haokets
- Hassan Hassan
- Hidden Cities
- Hisham Melhem
- HuffPost Maghreb
- Hugh Pope
- Ibishblog
- ICAHD
- Inanities
- Informed Comment
- IPCRI
- Ir Amim
- Iraq and Gulf Analysis
- Islawmix
- Israel Policy Forum Blog
- Israel Pulse: Al-Monitor
- Israel Spy
- Istanbul and Beyond
- J Street Blog
- Jacques Raillane
- Jadaliyya
- Jean-Pierre Filiu
- Jeffrey Goldberg
- Jim Meyer’s Borderlands
- Joel S. Migdal
- Jonathan Cook
- Jonathan Schanzer
- Kamel Daoud
- Kamil Pasha
- Karl reMarks
- Khaled Abu Toameh
- La Septième Wilaya
- Lahouari Addi
- Le Maghreb dans tous ses États
- Lettres d’Israël
- Maghreb Blog
- Maghreb Émergent
- MB in English
- MEI Editor’s Blog
- MEMRI
- MEMRI.fr
- MERIP
- Michael J. Totten
- Michael Young
- Middle East Eye
- Middle East Forum
- Middle East Policy Council
- Mideast Matrix
- Molad
- Mondoweiss
- Mosaic
- Muftah
- Mustafa Akyol
- New Israel Fund
- Nisralnasr
- Noura Erakat
- NOW
- Observatoire de la vie politique turque
- On the US and Israel
- Open Zion
- Orient XXI
- Ottomans and Zionists
- Palestine-Israel Journal
- Palestine Pulse: Al-Monitor
- Palestinian Centre for Human Rights
- Patriots on Fire
- Peace Now–Settlements
- Point of No Return
- POMEPS
- Poste de veille
- Qantara
- Qifa Nabki
- Rabbis for Human Rights
- Ramallah Café
- Rebel Economy
- Research Turkey
- Reuben Silverman
- Rosner’s Domain
- Rubin Center: IDC Herzliya
- Sada: CEIP
- Samia Serageldin’s Blog
- Sandbox
- Sandmonkey
- South Jerusalem
- Steven A. Cook
- Susam-Sokak.fr
- Synaps: The Slow Read
- Syria Comment
- Syria Deeply
- Ta’ayush
- Tablet–The Scroll
- Tabsir
- Temps et Contretemps
- Textures du temps
- The Arab Bureau Files
- The Arabist
- The Augean Stables
- The Back Channel: Al-Monitor
- The Blog of Palestinian Refugee ResearchNet
- The Contemplative Yurt
- The Daily Direnis
- The Electronic Intifada
- The Ettinger Report
- The Human Province
- The Istanbulian
- The Jahalin Association
- The Jerusalem Fund
- The Jewish Daily Forward
- The Magnes Zionist
- The Middle East Channel
- The Moor Next Door
- The Peace Now Blog
- The Rubin Report
- The Third Narrative
- The Third Way
- The Times of Israel
- The Tower
- The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer
- The Turkey Analyst
- Tunisie Libre
- Turkey Pulse: Al-Monitor
- Turkey Wonk
- TURKEYETC
- Turkish Politics Updates
- Turkish Press Review Blog
- Un œil sur la Syrie
- Un regard averti sur l’Algérie
- Yesh Din
- Ynetnews
- Yusuf Kanlı
BLOGROLL – USA
- All In with Chris Hayes
- Amanda Marcotte
- Andrew Sullivan
- Atlas Left
- Axios
- Bloggingheads
- Charles P. Pierce
- Conor Friedersdorf
- Crooked Media
- Crooks and Liars
- Daily Kos
- Danger Room
- Dave Zirin
- David Frum
- David Simon
- Democracy in America: The Economist
- Digby’s Hullabaloo
- Dirt Diggers Digest
- Eric Alterman
- Eschaton
- Ezra Klein
- FiveThirtyEight
- Frank Rich
- Glenn Greenwald
- Heather Cox Richardson
- Heather Digby Parton
- Hendrik Hertzberg
- Huffpolitics Blog
- Huffpost Pollster
- John Cassidy
- Jonathan Chait
- Kevin Drum
- Matt Taibbi
- Media Matters for America
- Michael Brendan Dougherty
- Michael Lind
- Molly Ball
- Michael Tomasky
- Moyers & Company
- Paul Waldman: TAP
- Paul Waldman: The Week
- Political Wire
- Politico
- Politicus USA
- Portside
- Princeton Election Consortium
- Raw Story
- Real Clear Politics
- Right-Wing Watch
- Ring of Fire
- Robert Reich
- Robert Shrum
- Roger Ebert’s Journal
- Ron Radosh
- Sabato’s Crystal Ball
- Salon
- Slate
- Ta-Nehisi Coates
- Talking Points Memo
- The American Conservative
- The American Prospect
- The Isaac Brock Society
- The Maddow Blog
- The Nation blogs
- The National Memo
- The New Republic
- The Plum Line
- The Ticker
- The Upshot: New York Times
- ThinkProgress
- Thomas B. Edsall
- TomDispatch.com
- Up w/Steve Kornacki
- VlogBrothers
- Vox
- Washington Monthly
- Wonkblog
- Wonkette
BLOGROLL – GEOPOLITICS & THE WORLD
- AFP: Correspondent/Behind the News
- Africa Is a Country
- Afrique Décryptages
- AI France Les Actus
- AI Livewire
- AI USA Blog
- Al Jazeera Blogs
- Amy Knight
- Andy Morgan Writes…
- Ask the Pilot
- Bernard Guetta: France Inter
- Borderlines
- Boulevard Extérieur
- Cato Institute: Foreign Policy and National Security
- CFR Blogs
- China in Africa: The Real Story
- Christopher Dickey
- Chrystia Freeland
- Daniel W. Drezner
- Democracy Arsenal
- Democracy Lab
- Democracy Now! Blog
- Euro-Islam.info
- European Council on Foreign Relations
- Foreign Affairs
- Foreign Policy
- Fortuna’s Corner
- Freedom at Issue
- Geographical Imaginations
- Human Rights Watch
- In Moscow’s Shadows
- Informed Comment: Global Affairs
- International Crisis Group
- James Fallows
- Julia Ioffe
- Latitude
- Le Blog de Pascal Boniface
- LobeLog
- Mondafrique
- Multicultural Meanderings
- My East-West
- Newshounding the World
- OpenDemocracy
- Passport
- Penser la Russie
- Peter Bergen
- Politique Étrangère
- Resurgent Dictatorship
- Roads & Kingdoms
- Robert Kagan
- RussEurope
- Russie-Libertés
- Sean’s Russia Blog
- SlateAfrique
- Small Wars Journal
- Soccer Politics
- Strange Maps
- Stephen M. Walt
- TerraNullius
- The Afternoon Map
- The American Interest
- The Belgravia Dispatch
- The Call
- The Global Journal
- The Globalist
- The Multilateralist
- The National Interest
- The Real News
- The World Blog
- Transmission
- Via Meadia
- View from Geneva
- War of Ideas
- World Elections
- World Policy Blog
- World Politics Review
- Worldcrunch
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
BLOGROLL – ECONOMICS
- Alter Éco Plus
- Alternatives Économiques
- Angry Bear
- Bernard Maris & Dominique Seux: France Inter
- Blog de Paul Jorion
- Brad DeLong
- Bruce Bartlett: Economix
- Bruce Bartlett: Fiscal Times
- Business Insider
- Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson
- Dean Baker
- Dominique Seux: France Inter
- Economic Scene
- Économie americaine
- Economix
- Evan Soltas
- Farhad Manjoo
- Felix Salmon
- Floyd Norris
- Henry Blodget
- INET Blog
- Jagdish Bhagwati
- James Surowiecki
- Jared Bernstein
- Jeffrey Sachs
- Joseph E. Stiglitz
- Marginal Revolution
- Mark Thoma
- Martin Wolf
- Matthew Yglesias
- Moneybox
- Naked Capitalism
- New Economic Perspectives
- Next New Deal
- Noahpinion
- Nouriel Roubini Blog
- Patrick Artus: Le Point
- Paul Krugman
- Robert H. Frank
- Robert Reich
- Schumpeter: The Economist
- Steve Keen’s Debtwatch
- The Becker-Posner Blog
- The Incidental Economist
- The Sports Economist
- Thomas Piketty
- Triple Crisis
- VoxEU
BLOGROLL – ACADEMIC, POLICY & INTELLO
- Adam Shatz
- Alexandre Afonso
- Balkinization
- Ballast
- Big Think
- Bipartisan Policy Center
- Blog of the Century
- Boston Review
- Brookings Up Front
- Center for American Progress
- Chez Michel Wieviorka
- City Journal
- Claire Berlinski
- Clive Davis
- Contreligne
- Contretemps
- Corey Robin
- Counterpoint
- Critical Inquiry: In the Moment
- Crooked Timber
- Dani Rodrik’s weblog
- Dart-Throwing Chimp
- Deliberately Considered
- Democracy: A Journal of Ideas
- Diane Ravitch’s blog
- Easily Distracted
- Esprit
- Fondapol
- Fondation IFRAP
- Fragments sur les temps présents
- Francis Fukuyama
- François Garçon
- George Monbiot
- ImmigrationProf Blog
- Jacobin Blogs
- Joel Kotkin
- Johnson: The Economist
- Justin Erik Halldór Smith
- Kenan Malik
- La Fondation Jean-Jaurès
- La Vie des idées
- Lawyers, Guns & Money
- LRB Blog
- Migrant Integration Policy Index (MIPEX)
- Migration Information Source
- Mischiefs of Faction
- New America Foundation
- Niskanen Center
- Normblog
- NYR Blog
- Opinio Juris
- OUPblog
- Pierre-André Taguieff
- Pláwlotic
- Policy Review
- Polit’bistro
- Political Violence @ a Glance
- Project Syndicate
- Prospect
- Quote Investigator
- Reason Hit & Run Blog
- Rebecca Schuman
- Russell Sage Foundation Blog
- Saideman’s Semi-Spew
- Sarah Kendzior
- Savage Minds Backup
- Simon A. Waldman
- Social Capital Blog
- South Writ Large
- TED Blog
- Telos
- Telos (France)
- Terra Nova
- The Broker
- The Browser
- The Conversation: Africa
- The Conversation: France
- The Conversation: UK
- The Conversation: US
- The Current Moment
- The Duck of Minerva
- The Immanent Frame
- The Monkey Cage
- The Naked Anthropologist
- The Optimistic Leftist: Ruy Teixeira
- The Paris Review Daily
- The Professor Is In
- The Upshot
- The Utopian
- Tom Pepinsky
- 100 Reasons NOT to Go to Graduate School
BLOGROLL – FRIENDS & FAMILY
Impressive movie – and I generally don’t like Haneke. The acting is especially wonderful.
On Haneke,’Caché’ was a very good film you will admit…
How to put it… Yes, Caché is a good movie, no doubt. I speak from very little experience: a few Haneke movies at best, including the utterly insufferable Funny Games. Caché is also painful to watch, like most Haneke’s movies. Its point (there is always one: bourgeois decadence, death, colonial guilt, etc) is also hammered in such a way that I quickly forgot the qualities of the film. I sympathize with the points Haneke makes in his movies, and find them formally brilliant – if I must be preached to, however, I prefer movies that play on a softer key.
Ultimately, there is the (rather childish, but what can I say?) idea that, in a world where evil stares us in the face every day, I like my moving pictures a bit more subtle, story-driven, entertaining. This makes me sound like a philistine, but there you have it.
“Amour” disappointed. I came prepared, even eager, to see a movie about the painful subject that “Amour” had the courage to treat.
It was wonderfully acted, nicely filmed, and brutally realistic.
But it was a bad movie.
In fact, it was barely a movie. Rather, it was a laborious exposition of a particularly painful way that people sometimes age, a situation that it laid out in a clinical but not in an artistic way.
It was as if someone set out to show how being poor sucks, and created a mise-en-scène that checked all the boxes to show how being poor sucks. It could be well-acted, well-filmed, and perfectly realistic, but still not be “a movie.”
“Amour” would have been more compelling had it probed more the dynamics between husband and wife, between parents and daughter, but these took a back seat to the meticulous, but often tedious, observation of the wife’s physical and mental decline.
Ricky: So you’re in the small minority of those who didn’t like the film http://www.allocine.fr/film/fichefilm-188067/critiques/ That’s okay. I don’t share your take, needless to say. In lieu of offering my counterpoint to your point, here is the response to your critique by AS, sent by email
AS’s comments have helped me to understand and appreciate the last scenes of the film. But by then “Amour” had worn me down. I stand by my overall impression that it was not so much about their love or their marriage as it was a clinical dissection of a certain, very difficult type of aging within a certain familial context.
I disagree when AS when he says, “There is also a powerful story about a marriage that is an exclusionary bond: Isabelle’s Huppert’s character is no more than a witness to their life together.” I saw no powerful story there. I found the daughter a wholly unsympathetic character, absorbed if not débordée by her own life, with a philandering husband, children she was not close to, and financial worries. She is upset and indignant to find her mother in decline as if she has a right to her mother remaining as she once was unto eternity, but one senses no warmth on her part toward her parents. So whether her parents relationship is “exclusionary” as AS put it is not tested by their self-absorbed daughter.
P.S. While the scenes with the symbolic pigeon went on way too long (as did several other scenes), I liked the pigeon as a symbol of death insofar as the essence of birds is to flee in the presence of humans. That this pigeon struts around as if Georges is not even there was a nice evocation that he is a ghost or about to become one.
Here’s an essay on the film by Teju Cole in The New Yorker, 6 Jan. 2013 http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/books/2013/01/age-actually.html